I finally was able to get my hands on some the cute cryptid pins and got two mothmans! Also got a Chonky cat pin and Haku from Spirited Away! I don't know
Coned Cryptozoology: Cryptid Hard Enamel Pins by KikiDoodle — Kickstarter
Cryptid Preservation Society" Pin for Sale by Mechanical-Koi | Redbubble
Nouveau Cryptid Enamel Pins
Cryptid Club Series II - Etsy | Enamel pins, Cute pins, Buttons pinback
Cute Cryptids Blind Bag Enamel Pin | Hot Topic
Cryptids Cryptozoology Badge Set of 4x 32mm Metal Pin Back - Etsy